
Certain sex offenders should be segregated from society, sometimes permanently. Unfortunately, the puritan streak in our society has been labeling a portion of people engaging in criminal lapses of judgment with the scarlet letter for life, in violation of the Constitution's 9th Amendment against cruel and unusual punishment. Should a 19-year-old person who committed the act of statutory rape with a 15-year-old girlfriend be permanently barred from any contact with any child, and shunned from communities, permanently branded (digitally, now that sex offenders can be looked up online).
Having connections to my state's protective services for children, I've heard my share of stories where it ends well for no one. The branding seems permanent: there's no common legal process for getting the restriction lifted across the different states.
Aggravating this is the paranoia of the scarlet letter syndrome: "Oh my god! There's a sex offender in our neighborhood? Call out the parents! Break out the pitchforks! Picket their house! Harass them in public!"
I've got kids. I worry about sex offenders, and if someone were to attack my kids, I don't know that I'd show civil restraint. Hopefully I won't get to that point. But the fact is many of these "offenders" are paying for their entire lives for a SINGLE indiscretion. While this information is available online (at the same places where
you can find fancy maps, like the one above), it's misleading. Not the offenses: while I've found lots of single-offenders (blue on the map). Behind each conviction is a sad story, an offender who was only caught once... the stories number more than the blips on the map. The point is that these people are all tossed in the same, tainted pile. Chased from address to address, neighborhood to neighborhood.
And when someone does the right thing, providing a legal space for them to exist, the neighbors are up in arms. Yeah, having a bus stop near a sex-offender neighborhood is tough. But they need a way to get to work. Do the neighbor thing and walk your children to and from school. Do they (delusionally) think that dispersing the sex offenders will solve anything? It just increases the odds of a drive-through pedophile snatching a child. We've had two attempts near where my kids live -- odds are they weren't from the neighborhood.
We live in a dangerous world. But repeatedly punishing people who've already been through the system and are keeping their word and legally registering should
not be further punished. It only increases the chance they'll simply drop out of the system, live wherever they want, and be lurking dangers in many neighborhoods. Or, more likely, just live their lives, glad to be temporarily free of the cloud over their lives.